Is Your Dog Sneaky? Study Finds Dogs Use Deception on Humans
Do you consider your dog sneaky? Has your dog ever deceived you? If so you’re not alone. New research suggests that dogs use deception to get what they want, especially when it comes to food.
The study was conducted by Marianne Heberlein of the Department of Evolutionary Biology & Experimental Studies at the University of Zurich. After observing her own dogs tricking one another (pretending to see something interesting outside to get the better lounging spot) she set out to find out if dogs used such tricky techniques to deceive humans as well.
How the Study Was Conducted
The study involved 27 dogs, each of which were paired their owner (who always gave treats) and two different partners – the generous one and the competitive one. To establish which partner was generous or competitive the dogs were taught to “find the food” by leading each of their partners to two boxes, both of which contained a treat. The generous partner would always give the dog the treat from the box, while the competitive partner kept it for herself.
After the dogs had established which partner was generous and which was greedy they were given a new task. The dogs watched as a sausage, a biscuit or nothing was placed under three new boxes. The dogs were then told to “find the food” witch each of their partners, choosing between the three boxes. As with the first test when the dogs led the generous partner to a box containing a treat the partner gave it to them, while the competitive partner kept the treat to herself.
After the dogs led their two partners to one of the three boxes they were reunited back with their owner. The owner would then take them back to the same boxes and ask them to choose one. If the box they chose had a treat the owner would always give it to them, but if they chose one of the boxes that they’d chosen before the owner would lift it up to show them that it was empty.
The Results of the Study
They continued this task for a two-day testing period. The dogs were trained to lead their partner to a box containing food, yet they started to understand that the competitive partner would not let them have the treat. On the first day the dogs led the generous partner to the sausage box more often than you’d expect by chance. And on the second day the dogs began leading the competitive partner (the greedy one who kept the treats to herself) to the empty box more frequently.
The researchers were surprised at how quickly some of the dogs figured out how to get all the snacks for themselves. A few of the dogs were leading the competitive partner to the empty box on the very first trial, thus finding a way to get all the treats themselves.
The study finds that dogs are able to distinguish between cooperative and competitive partners, and that they’re able to use tactical deception to their own advantage. The research suggests that the dogs were weighing their options, and engaging in deliberate deception to maximize their chances of getting both treats.
This study is further indication of how sophisticated dog cognition is, and that our dogs are much smarter (and sneakier) than we give them credit for. And if you thought your dog was sneaky you can now cite this study as proof. And although this is just one study it does show how highly flexible dogs are in their own behavior, especially when it comes to getting extra treats.
Many dogs are smart, but I do not think they are sneaky!
my dog tries to be sneaky, except she tries to be sneaky when she wants to snuggle or sit on your lap. first comes one paw, then another, then she scoots up more onto you…
They’re so funny like that, aren’t they?
Yes. I used to have a dog who knew she was supposed to sleep on someone’s room at night so that she couldn’t get into stuff, but when she slept with my brother he always left the door open. So she would sneak out the room and to keep us from hearing her she would walk a different way so that her claws wouldn’t touch the floor. We had hard wood floor and usually you could hear her walking due to her claws. No one managed to figure out how she was doing it until my dad came home from work late one night and caught her. So yes dogs know what they are and aren’t supposed to do and if they want to do it anyway they will be sneaky. https://esacare.com/role-of-esa-in-treating-psychological-disorders/
Your research is very interesting, thank you!
We have a dog who is well behaved WHEN THERE IS A WITNESS. But, he will scurry to get into something he shouldn’t immediately after the witness leaves the room. We have a camera set up and you can watch it happen. He never just hangs out and then randomly gets into something because he got bored. Rather, he watches and listens to be sure you are away and then he darts in to do his bad deeds (e.g. grabbing a piece of food off you plate, lifting tissues out of the container to shred, robbing the bathroom trash for toilet paper cores to destroy, pulling empty water bottles out of recycling box…).
We just had a disagreement today in our home because my DH read that dogs don’t strategize and sneak. Somehow he believes they just love us SOOOO much that when we aren’t in the room to occupy their thoughts, they turn to other interests. Lol. Whatever. The Narcissistic dog owner’s theory of why a dog that knows better does a jerk thing as soon as you leave the room, I guess?
But the timing of when he does it says a lot. He does it immediately. Like, he knows you will eventually come back and so he does his deeds quickly!