My Love/Hate Relationship With Retractable Leashes
This post is in response to what I found to be an unusually high number of “what’s the best leash?” searches happening here on the blog.
My answer? Well certainly not a retractable one if you want something reliable. If you’re looking for a leash for your dog it’s hard to go wrong with a standard 6 foot one.
My Love/Hate Relationship With Retractable Leashes
A few weeks ago I spoke out against using retractable leashes for dog walks.
I still stand by that. Retractable leashes are bad for dog walks. They’re horrible when it comes to keeping control of your dog, and they can be pretty dangerous.
But I have to confess; I use a retractable leash at least 3 times a day.
Why I Love My Retractable Leash
I’ve never been a big fan of leaving my dogs unattended in the yard. I know many people rely on a fence or chain to keep their dog safe, but that’s not something I’m comfortable with.
So at least three times a day I accompany Laika out to the yard to do her business, and I use my retractable leash every single time. I still use a standard 6 foot leash when we go for walks, but the retractable one is used for all her yard business.
We live on 3 fenced in acres, but that fence is only 4 feet high. I could just let her go leash free but there’s never a shortage of deer, turkeys, rabbits, squirrels, moles, or cats running about. I learned pretty quickly that a 4 foot fence means nothing to a dog that’s chasing a squirrel.
And then of course there’s the times when she’s managed to catch those cute little baby bunnies & turkeys. She didn’t hurt them physically, though psychologically I’m not so sure. She just casually brought them back to me and handed them off when I told her to “drop it.”
Instead of watching my dog terrorize animals and flush out our backyard every day I opted for a retractable leash. Yes, her recall is pretty good, but it’s never going to be perfect; especially with all those pesky little squirrels are around.
And then there’s her legs. Due to arthritis one quick sprint can put her out of commission for the night. She certainly doesn’t hesitate to take off after deer, but it’s pretty sad having to watch your dog limp all night because of it.
So I use my retractable leash every day to cut down on all that chaos. I’ve had mornings where I was late for work because I decided to let her go leash free. On those fun mornings she opted to chase down those gang of turkeys, packs of deer, or evil squirrels rather than come back to me.
For me the leash is a matter of convenience. Sure I could use a long line, but my simple brain can’t get over the fact that I can just reel in a leash with the push of a button. Wheee, look at it go. For me that button is just as fun as having a lever to automatically wind up the cord on your vacuum. Wheee, look at it go.
That button works about 90% of the time. Retractable leashes, as I’ve come to find out, aren’t that reliable when it comes to working as intended.
I do this to keep the baby bunnies safe Laika…Even when they eat all my spinach, I’m doing this for them.
Why I Hate Retractable Leashes
Retractable leashes are far from perfect. I’ve had many instances where Laika’s took off while on it, and those sent me falling right to the ground.
And when she does manage to run off while on it she ends up getting stuck. That stupid leash gets stuck on nearly every branch, pricker bush or bramble it comes into contact with.
Did I mention that I’m on our 4th one? Yeah, turns out they’re pretty flimsy and have a tendency to snap.
They are unreliable, and when it comes to keeping control of your dog just forget about it. You’ll likely end up on the ground, burning your hand from trying to grip the cord, or holding onto that awkwardly large handle for dear life.
The Moral of the Story
When it comes to retractable leashes I really do have a love/hate relationship. One one hand I know they’re terribly unreliable, on the other hand I keep using mine every single day for the convenience.
When given choices we opt for convenience, even if we know there’s probably a better option.
I keep buying these stupid retractable leashes because for the most they make it easy for me to supervise when Laika’s gotta do her business.
Could I just get a long line instead? Of course. But then I wouldn’t get that fun wheeee moment as I watch my leash do that automatically. I’d have to manually reel it in, and in my simple mind that just sounds like a lot more work.
Perhaps it’s more to do with familiarity. For the most part the retractable leash keeps Laika & the baby animals safe, so it must be working…
Oh how our minds have a way of sticking with the status quo, regardless of outward signs that it might not be the best option.
Perhaps one day I’ll wise up and choose a leash that won’t snap, won’t drop me to my knees everytime my dog pulls, and won’t burn my hands as I try to grab onto it. Until then I suppose I’ll just keep on using my retractable leash, it’s what I’m familiar with after all…
Do You Use a Retractable Leash?
Do you have a retractable leash? Do you use it on walks or trips to the park? Do you find it convenient? Do you love the automatic reel in button as much as I do?
With four dogs, retractable leashes are a nightmare for me. I have zero control over them and now understand why people speak out against these leashes. I think a retractable leash would work with Sydney, because she’s such a mellow dog that doesn’t venture away from me. I like the idea of changing the length for when we’re at the vet’s office to keep her close, keep her on the scale, or allow her to move away when she needs to potty.
I just use a regular leash though.
I think a lot of the trouble with the retractables is the user and not using common sense. We use them often, but in areas where there are no other dogs/people, etc. It’s a great way for us to chase a squirrel if we want but still be on leash. We use a short leash when we go places, or if we are in a busy area. We know how to walk on leash which makes a big difference. Most of the time, even on the retractable, we are within a couple feet of mom. We’ve never had one malfunction, but we only use Flexi brand ones, and the ones with the tape, not a rope. We also walk in an order, so we never have issues with tangling, but many people out there are truly out of control with flexis and it is not a good thing.
I agree with @disqus_idBDzxzkIC:disqus that the problem usually occurs with the users not using common sense when using the retractable leashes. We use our regular 6 foot leash most of the time, but we do have a retractable leash that we use from time to time when working on recalls. And yes I do like using the retractable over the long line so I can have the fun wheee moment. 🙂
We use a retractable leash for potty breaks, too. I especially like it when it’s snowy because I can stand on the cleared back patio and Barley can go much farther out into the snow to take care of business than she can on her short leash. We’ve definitely had some mishaps when she’s taken off after a squirrel and I didn’t see it in time to prepare myself by pushing the button and gripping a little tighter–and she has a knack for wrapping it around trees and shrubs and somehow getting it around EVERY SINGLE branch–but it is so much more convenient than using her long line (which we do use every now and then) since that is always getting knots in the middle. I’m glad I’m not the only one with a love/hate relationship with them.
It’s the best thing ever in the winter, I agree. And yes, they do have a tendency to get caught on every single tiny little branch 🙂
No, I do not use them and I don’t recommend them either for precisely the reasons mentioned. Most people don’t know how to use them and if for some odd reason you managed to drop the retractable compartment, your dog is now being ‘chased’ by something. We had a dog go missing a few months back in the next town over and he was found a few days later, with his retractable leash wrapped around a tree.
We also have those DADO’s in my neighborhood that let their dogs wander here, there and everywhere. I imagine if the person is dog savvy and pays attention, they might be okay. 🙂
I 100000 percent HATE retractable leashes! I was looking after a King Shepherd, and the only leash the owner had for him was retractable. We walked through a field, he spotted a gopher, and took off running. The leash snapped under his strength, came flying back, and hit me in the stomach. Worst pain I’ve ever felt!
I also read an article where a teenage girl had the same thing happen but hit her in the eye instead, and she is now blind in that eye.
Screw retractable leashes!